Blackout Blinds vs. Blackout Curtains: Which Option is Right for You?
In today’s chaotic, privacy-deprived world, a restful night’s sleep and the ability to isolate yourself from prying eyes can be considered the greatest treasures a person can possess. Although the definition of “treasure” is “something that’s difficult to obtain”, in this case - that’s not the case!
Tailor-made blackout curtains and custom blackout blinds in New York City are accessible, affordable, and great for creating a restful, private environment in your home. But, which option is better for you? Let’s dive in and find out!
What is better: blackout blinds or blackout curtains?
The truth is, both options are excellent, whether you want to enhance your sleep quality, improve privacy, or block out the outside light for any other reason. However, depending on your needs and preferences in terms of functionality, aesthetics, and cost, one option will definitely suit you better than the other. Let’s break down these characteristics to help you gauge which blackout window treatment should be your go-to.
Functionality: The light-blocking potential
Both blackout blinds and curtains excel at blocking light - after all, that’s what they’re made for. However, in terms of effectiveness, the former outshines the latter:
Blackout blinds are specifically engineered to maximize light blockage, with some models achieving a near-total blackout effect. Their design enables the blinds to fit snuggly within the window frame, with some variants featuring side channels or additional seals to minimize recess light “leakage”.
Functionality score: 9/10
Blackout curtains are intended to balance the aesthetic appeal and light-blocking capabilities. As such, they’re not as effective as their counterpart, especially if they’re not properly installed. If they don’t fit tightly against the window or if the curtain rod is not correctly positioned, the light may seep from the top and the sides. However, layering the curtains with sheer or standard ones may increase their light-blocking potential.
Functionality score (basic): 6/10
Functionality score (layered): 7/10
The Verdict: Blinds definitely take the cake in terms of overall functionality, making them a better choice if you want near-total darkness.
Aesthetics: Look does matter
Whether you choose blinds or curtains, they will become an integral part of your home. You’ll look at them every day and, as such, they should match your style and contribute to the overall appearance of your space.
Blackout blinds (modern variants) come in various styles, colors, and material options, making them easy to fit into virtually any environment. Since they can be mounted inside or outside the window frame, they take up less space than curtains which results in a clean, streamlined, and minimalistic appearance - ideal for contemporary interiors.
Style score (traditional or ornate decor): 6/10
Style score (modern or minimalistic decor): 9/10
Blackout curtains are available in an insane array of styles, colors, textures, and patterns, meaning they can be a perfect fit for any interior decor. Plus, they can be layered with decorative drapes, adding to the dramatic effect (and overall appeal).
Style score (traditional, ornate, or classic decor): 10/10
Style score (other decor): 9/10
The Verdict: Ultimately, this is all about your preference. If you value aesthetics over functionality, curtains are a better choice - and vice versa.
Cost: Quantifying the value
The price of both blackout blinds and curtains can vary dramatically, depending on their size, choice of materials, and additional features.
Blackout blinds can range in price from relatively affordable (for simple, roller variants) to very expensive (for custom-made, motorized, smart variants) and anything in between. However, despite the higher initial investment, they are widely considered a better long-term option due to their innate durability.
Price score (simple variants): 9/10
Price score (advanced/smart variants): 6/10
Price score (long-term value): 9/10
Blackout curtains are generally considered a more cost-effective option, especially if you go for ready-made variants. However, their price can easily reach and even surpass the blinds with tailor-made designs featuring premium/luxury fabric and linings. Plus, they may require additional hardware and fabric typically deteriorates much faster.
Price score (ready-made variants): 10/10
Price score (custom/luxury variants): 6/10
Price score (long-term value): 7/10
The Verdict: Longer life expectancy, paired with the possibility of adding functionality features, is why blackout blinds offer a better ROI, albeit by a narrow margin.
The middle ground
As you’ve concluded by now, both the blackout blinds and curtains have their strengths and weaknesses. This can make selecting one or the other a daunting task. However, there is a third option, which too few people consider:
Their distinct designs and installation methods (i.e., in-frame for blinds and mounted for curtains), make both window treatments not only compatible - but complementary! That’s right, you can combine them and have the best of both worlds!
